Is Monetary Policy Losing its Power?

This article explores how the effectiveness of monetary policy in recent times has been questioned, with its limitations increasingly at play.

Insights

What has happened?

Monetary Policy has been historically very effective. Over the past 20 years, the average inflation rate has been 1.5% and Economic growth at 3%. During the GFC, despite globally recessive economic conditions, Australia was able to maintain an economic growth of 1.4%. This is largely attributable to RBA’s massive cash rate cuts of 100 basis points from 7% to 6%  which allowed for the vigorous monetary growth that Australia needed at the time. In addition during the Mining Boom of 2011, unprecedented levels of investment and export growth catapulted GDP growth to 4.2% and inflation to 3.2%. A contractionary monetary policy stance initiated by the RBA  prevented the overheating of our economy, with inflation being contained within 2-3% and GDP growth dropping to 3.9%. 


However, the effectiveness of monetary policy has been questioned in recent times. The RBA has been gradually slashing the cash rate for the past 16 months, in an attempt to increase aggregate demand through the transmission mechanism, and thereby stabilise our economic fundamentals.

At the beginning of 2019 the cash rate stood at a figure of 1.5%, but this declined to 0.25% as of April 2020, a historic low. However, economic growth, inflation and unemployment still remain out of their respective target bands.

GDP growth has ranged between 1.4% and 2.2% in the past year and a half, considerably lower than the medium term trend in the past 5 years of about 2.8%. Inflation has hovered around 1.5% since 2016, and is currently 1.8%, below the RBA’s target band of 2-3%. Moreover unemployment has remained between 5-6% in the last 4 years, above the NAIRU of 4.5%. 


The reason why the transmission mechanism has been largely unsuccessful is because the limitations of monetary policy are now increasingly at play. These include the long and variable impact  time lag of monetary policy, the contradiction of fiscal and monetary policy and the blunt instrument effect, to name a few (will be further discussed in the syllabus links section). Perhaps, monetary policy is losing its power and we need to consider newer, more radical approaches such as quantitative easing or modern monetary theory (will be explored in upcoming extension articles). 

As can be observed, drastic cuts to our cash rate have been made in the past couple years in order to combat our declining economic fundamentals. 


Syllabus Links

Impact of changes in interest rates on economic activity- transmission mechanism

Economists describe the process through which monetary policy impacts upon the economy as the transmission mechanism. It explains how changes in the stance of monetary policy pass through the economy to influence objectives such as inflation, economic growth and unemployment. 

The first transmission mechanism is known as the savings channel. The RBA’s rate cuts in the past 16 months mean consumers have less incentive to save due to lower returns. Since Y = C  + S, a fall in savings will correspond to an increase in consumption, which then directly stimulates Aggregate Demand (AD = C + I + G + X - M). This leads to greater GDP growth, inflation and lower unemployment in the short run. 

The next transmission mechanism is the investment channel. A reduced cash rate and therefore interest rates reduces the cost of borrowing for newly established businesses looking to undertake investment and expand their firm. Existing borrowers also now need less money to service corporate loans, leading to additional spending and further investment. Investment is a direct component of aggregate demand (AD = C + I + G + X - M). Therefore an increase in the level of business investment would also correlate with an increase in GDP growth and hence demand pull inflation in the medium term. The investment channel is best captured through the diagrams below.


Here the decrease of cash rate from (Cash Rate 0 to Cash Rate 1) correlates with an increase in investment (Investment 0 to investment 1)

The final transmission mechanism is the exchange rate channel. A fall in the level of interest rates would discourage financial inflow into Australia, leading to a decrease in demand for the AUD, and therefore a depreciation. A depreciation makes Australia more competitive in both domestic markets (since imports are more expensive), and overseas markets (since exports are cheaper). Therefore, with greater exports and lower imports, Aggregate Demand increases (AD = C + I + G + X - M) , stimulating economic growth and adding to inflation. Higher output also generates greater levels of employment, as labour is a derived demand. 

Limitations of Monetary Policy 

Monetary policy has a wide range of limitations, which has significantly downplayed its effectiveness in the past 16 months. These limitations include: 

  • Monetary policy is a blunt instrument meaning that it cannot be directed at specific parts of the economy, and is only able to increase Aggregate Demand as a whole. Therefore it fails to address the structural causes behind low inflation, including low wages growth, the decentralisation of labour, and weak household consumption.
  • The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority’s (APRA's) credit and lending tightening has made it significantly harder for individuals and businesses to borrow money despite the incentive provided through the lower cash rate. 
  • Monetary Policy has a long and variable time lag of 6-18 months as it is dependent on businesses and consumers changing their financial behaviours. Hence it is unable to facilitate an economic boom immediately, which the economy requires. 
  • There is currently a lack of coordination between Fiscal and Monetary policy. While the RBA is pursuing an expansionary stance, the Australian government is doing the opposite with their 2019-20 budget forecasting a surplus of 7.1 billion dollars. The contradiction between the two macro policies counteracts and minimises the expansionary effects of the RBA’s cash rate cuts. 
  • Monetary Policy continues to lose its effectiveness as it approaches the lower bound of 0, as it is more accustomed to contracting the economy. The lowering cash rate raises the prospect of significant issues such as banks refusing to pass on cuts to their respective interest rates. 

Feel free to ask any questions on our discussion board and hope you are back for next week’s articles!


Sign up below to be notified when our new articles are published.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

References